Loading the registry…
River Review turns review into an organizational judgment asset: Review Judgment as Code delivered as a capability pack with a Skill Registry of versioned review skills and a perspective-based review agent. This package holds the docs, schemas, and validation utilities.
We found this by crawling public sources and nobody has attested to it. That is how most of the registry gets here, and it is not a mark against the artifact — it only means no authenticated act of publication is on record. An artifact can be the vendor's own and still appear here.
74 critical findings reported by cisco-skill-scanner, 42 of them in the installed artifact. The composite score alone does not reflect this — read the per-scanner reports below.
Choose your runtime: the CLI writes the mcpServers config entry for that target.
nerlo install --target claude-code -- river-review
Install respects the composite badge: Clean proceeds, Caution prompts for confirmation, and Flagged is refused. Write operations require an API token.
7 of 11 scanners examined this package. The rest do not apply to it — language, ecosystem and packaging decide which analyzers can say anything, and a scanner that cannot examine an artifact reports nothing rather than passing it.
v1.4.0
Incomplete run
26 findings · 1.4s
v2.0.11
1222 findings · 64.4s
v0.3.74
22 findings · 21.0s
v0.1.0
1 finding · 10.8s
v0.1.0
40 findings · 10.8s
v0.71.0
1 finding · 1.6s
v2.3.8
5 findings · 10.2s
vv0.3.2
No Go packages were found in this artifact. What each scanner covers
0 findings · 0.1s
v0.1.0
This scanner found nothing in this artifact that it assesses. What each scanner covers
0 findings · 1.6s
v0.71.0
No container image was published for this artifact. What each scanner covers
0 findings · 0.0s
vv1.6.0
No Go modules were found in this artifact. What each scanner covers
0 findings · 0.1s
1 scan on record. Every scan's full results are retained immutably for 24 months.
| Completed | Composite | Change | Scanners | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 22, 2026 | Flagged35 | — | agentshield ·!: incompletecisco-skill-scanner: completeagent-audit-kit: completenerlo-behavioral: completenerlo-install-instruction: completecapslock ·n/a: not applicablenerlo-multi-source ·n/a: not applicabletrivy: completeosv-scanner: completetrivy_image ·n/a: not applicablegovulncheck ·n/a: not applicable | completed |
Findings in files this artifact installs stand as reported; a model re-read the rest and said which ones it believes are false positives. This is a second opinion published beside the evidence, not a correction to it: the per-scanner reports above are unchanged, every dismissed finding is still listed there at its original severity, and the score and the Flagged badge are computed from those raw severities alone. Nothing below moved them.
Out of 1,317 findings across every scanner that examined this package. 21 of 74 findings rated critical by their scanner were among the dismissals.
Not reviewed is not the same as clean. Those 456 findings stand exactly as their scanners reported them, at full severity, as they would have without this review.
Two keys had to turn. The model had to name a reason from a fixed list of six, and a deterministic check of ours — over which files this artifact actually installs — had to independently agree. Anything it could not corroborate is in “not reviewed” above, at full severity.
57 Documentation or example — The match is in documentation or sample code, confirmed by our own check to be outside the installed artifact.
Rules: FILE_MAGIC_MISMATCH, AAK-LEGAL-002, LOW_ANALYZABILITY and 1 more · Files: /repo/skills/midstream/review-criteria-integrity/fixtures/02-threshold-and-suppression-relaxation-detect.md, /repo/skills/agent-skills/unknown-coverage-review/fixtures/01-pass-evidence-sufficient.md, /repo/skills/midstream/i18n-unused-key/fixtures/02-dynamic-key-false-positive.md and 14 more · reported by cisco-skill-scanner, agent-audit-kit
44 Test or fixture file — The match is in a test or fixture. Our own check confirmed the file is not part of what gets installed.
Rules: COMMAND_INJECTION_JS_CHILD_PROCESS, COMMAND_INJECTION_EVAL, COMMAND_INJECTION_JS_FUNCTION_CONSTRUCTOR and 9 more · Files: /repo/tests/cli-ensemble-flag.test.mjs, /repo/tests/cli-review-exec-replay.test.mjs, /repo/tests/feedback-rule-candidates.test.mjs and 21 more · reported by cisco-skill-scanner, agent-audit-kit
5 Agent instruction file — The match is in a file that instructs an AI coding agent — a CLAUDE.md or similar. It is documentation of intent, and our own check confirmed it is not part of what gets installed.
Rules: AAK-AGENT-003, AAK-AGENT-005, AAK-AGENT-001 · Files: CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md · reported by agent-audit-kit
3 CI or editor configuration — The match is in build, CI or editor configuration, confirmed by our own check to be outside the installed artifact.
Rules: AAK-GHA-IMMUTABLE-001, SOCIAL_ENG_VAGUE_DESCRIPTION, MANIFEST_INVALID_NAME · Files: .github/workflows/scorecard.yml, /repo/.github/prompts/SKILL.md, /repo/.github/SKILL.md · reported by agent-audit-kit, cisco-skill-scanner
These findings are in files this artifact installs and are not placeholder values. No false-positive basis can be corroborated for such a finding, so this review never dismisses one; they were not sent to the model and stand at their scanner's severity.
235 MANIFEST_MISSING_LICENSE
Files: /repo/.claude/skills/skill-creator/SKILL.md, /repo/.claude/skills/ask-codex/SKILL.md, /repo/.claude/skills/river-review-discipline/SKILL.md and 232 more · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
126 DATA_EXFIL_JS_FS_ACCESS
Files: /repo/plugins/river-dashboard/index.js, /repo/runners/core/skill-loader.mjs, /repo/runners/github-action/dist/602.index.mjs and 48 more · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
121 MANIFEST_INVALID_NAME
Files: /repo/skills/upstream/context-budget-tuning/SKILL.md, /repo/skills/midstream/design-system-component-reuse/SKILL.md, /repo/skills/upstream/code-php-laravel/SKILL.md and 118 more · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
105 SOCIAL_ENG_VAGUE_DESCRIPTION
Files: /repo/SKILL.md, /repo/.codex/SKILL.md, /repo/skills/SKILL.md and 102 more · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
33 COMMAND_INJECTION_EVAL
Files: /repo/runners/github-action/dist/157.index.mjs, /repo/runners/github-action/dist/252.index.mjs, /repo/runners/github-action/dist/343.index.mjs and 9 more
432 The model's answer could not be read.
Rules: HIDDEN_DATA_FILE, skills-missing-governance-commands/merge-check.md, skills-missing-telemetry-commands/verify-agent-report.md and 13 more · Files: /repo/tests/fixtures/plangate-review-artifacts/config/.river-review.json, commands/merge-check.md, commands/verify-agent-report.md and 198 more · reported by cisco-skill-scanner, agentshield, nerlo-install-instruction
24 The model called these false positives and our own check did not agree, so the dismissal was refused.
Rules: SECRET_GITHUB_TOKEN, SECRET_AWS_KEY, SECRET_CONNECTION_STRING and 10 more · Files: /repo/tests/heuristic-review.test.mjs, /repo/tests/llm-adjudicator.test.mjs, /repo/skills/midstream/secret-credential-scan/fixtures/SKILL.md and 8 more · reported by cisco-skill-scanner, agentshield
Artifact contains critical command injection vulnerabilities and exposed secrets.
The artifact includes code with critical command injection vulnerabilities, particularly in `/repo/runners/cli/src/commands/create.mjs` and various `index.mjs` files within `/repo/runners/github-action/dist/`. It also exposes GitHub tokens, AWS keys, and connection strings. Additionally, the artifact performs shell execution via pipe-to-shell operations and may egress secrets over the network.
Concern level assessed by the review: Critical. This is the review's scale, not the registry badge.
Reviewed by gemini-2.5-flash. The model sees the findings, not your code, and cannot change a score.
24 HIDDEN_DATA_FILE
Files: /repo/.river/ai-review/static/bot-commands.md, /repo/.lycheeignore, /repo/.river/ai-review/static/plans-and-costs.md and 21 more · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
16 DATA_EXFIL_JS_NETWORK
Files: /repo/runners/github-action/dist/index.mjs, /repo/runners/node-api/dist/index.js, /repo/runners/node-api/src/index.ts and 1 more · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
16 opt.nerlo-rules.nerlo-install-run-bundled-artifact
Files: /repo/pages/guides/agent-workflow.en.md, /repo/pages/guides/governance/skill-policy.en.md, /repo/pages/guides/governance/skill-policy.md and 3 more · reported by nerlo-install-instruction
8 YARA_capability_inflation_generic
Files: /repo/runners/github-action/dist/index.mjs · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
6 COMMAND_INJECTION_JS_FUNCTION_CONSTRUCTOR
Files: /repo/runners/github-action/dist/index.mjs · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
6 FILE_MAGIC_MISMATCH
Files: /repo/scripts/templates/skill/prompt/user.md, /repo/skills/_template.md, /repo/static/llms.txt · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
5 LOW_ANALYZABILITY
Files: /repo/runners/github-action, /repo/runners/core, /repo and 2 more · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
4 opt.nerlo-rules.nerlo-install-pipe-to-shell
Files: /repo/CHANGELOG.md, /repo/scripts/setup-codex.sh, /repo/skills/downstream/gha-workflow-security/golden/01-script-injection-happy.md and 1 more · reported by nerlo-install-instruction
4 PIPELINE_TAINT_FLOW
Files: /repo/scripts/setup-codex.sh, /repo/templates/agent-workflow/README.md, /repo/templates/agent-workflow/SKILL.md · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
3 AAK-LEGAL-002
Files: runners/node-api/package.json, runners/core/package.json, runners/cli/package.json · reported by agent-audit-kit
3 COMMAND_INJECTION_JS_CHILD_PROCESS
Files: /repo/scripts/evaluate-all.mjs, /repo/scripts/check-comment-disposition.mjs · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
3 EXCESSIVE_FILE_COUNT
Files: /repo/skills/., /repo/., /repo/pages/. · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
3 GHSA-5p4m-2wfm-xmqj
Files: /repo/package-lock.json, package-lock.json · reported by osv-scanner, trivy
2 AAK-IPI-WILD-CORPUS-001
Files: skills/downstream/gha-workflow-security/golden/01-script-injection-happy.md, skills/upstream/plan-review-gate/SKILL.md · reported by agent-audit-kit
2 AAK-SKILL-005
Files: skills/midstream/closure-scope-retention/SKILL.md, skills/midstream/altitude-generalization/SKILL.md · reported by agent-audit-kit
2 LAZY_LOAD_DEEP_NESTING
Files: /repo/pages/explanation/SKILL.md, /repo/pages/reference/SKILL.md · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
2 OBFUSCATION_XOR_ENCODING
Files: /repo/runners/github-action/dist/index.mjs · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
2 opt.nerlo-rules.nerlo-install-fetch-raw-then-run
Files: /repo/scripts/setup-codex.sh, /repo/templates/agent-workflow/README.md · reported by nerlo-install-instruction
1 AAK-MARKETPLACE-001
Files: .claude-plugin/marketplace.json · reported by agent-audit-kit
1 AAK-MCP-ARGV-TOCTOU-001
Files: src/cli.mjs · reported by agent-audit-kit
1 AAK-OAUTH-007
Files: src/config/schema.mjs · reported by agent-audit-kit
1 AAK-SECRET-006
Files: .env.example · reported by agent-audit-kit
1 AAK-SUPPLY-003
Files: package.json · reported by agent-audit-kit
1 AAK-SUPPLY-005
Files: package-lock.json · reported by agent-audit-kit
1 GHSA-2v37-7h3g-55p8
Files: /repo/package-lock.json · reported by osv-scanner
1 GHSA-5p2g-fcmc-qvqq
Files: /repo/package-lock.json · reported by osv-scanner
1 GHSA-w3rx-r6r6-pgpr
Files: /repo/package-lock.json · reported by osv-scanner
1 hooks-logging-disabled-1512
Files: hooks/gh-account-guard.sh · reported by agentshield
1 hooks-logging-disabled-2422
Files: hooks/no-force-push.sh · reported by agentshield
1 hooks-logging-disabled-2825
Files: hooks/no-force-push.sh · reported by agentshield
1 hooks-no-stop-hooks
Files: settings.json · reported by agentshield
1 opt.nerlo-rules.nerlo-install-shell-inline-command
Files: /repo/.claude/hooks/README.md · reported by nerlo-install-instruction
1 opt.nerlo-rules.nerlo-js-secret-to-network-egress
Files: /repo/runners/node-api/src/index.ts · reported by nerlo-behavioral
1 permissions-missing-deny->-/dev/
Files: settings.json · reported by agentshield
1 permissions-missing-deny-chmod-777
Files: settings.json · reported by agentshield
1 permissions-missing-deny-ssh
Files: settings.json · reported by agentshield
1 SECRET_CONNECTION_STRING
Files: /repo/skills/midstream/secret-credential-scan/golden/SKILL.md · reported by cisco-skill-scanner
1 skills-missing-governance-skills/README.md
Files: skills/README.md · reported by agentshield
1 skills-missing-telemetry-skills/README.md
Files: skills/README.md · reported by agentshield
Showing 25 of 81; the rest are in the per-scanner reports above.